Debt counselling vs review vs consolidation (which is best?)

Each debt option is closely related, but has key differences; here's a true comparison between debt counselling, debt review, and debt consolidation loans.
Written by
Reviewed by
Contents
Specialist team member
Remember, if you'd like to learn how to legally reduce your debt, we can connect you with a debt expert.

 

Debt counselling, debt review, and debt consolidation loans all solve similar problems. But they’re not the same.

Today, we’ll compare these three debt options, get into their definitions, purpose, advantages and disadvantages, and more.

In the end, you’ll know which option is best for you — debt counselling and review (the red pill) or debt consolidation loans (the blue pill.)

Let’s get into it.

Contents

Debt counselling vs debt review vs debt consolidation loans

Learning about these three debt-related services for the first time can be confusing.

There’s a lot of overlap between them. Making it easy to mix them up.

Let’s start by defining each one before looking at where they fit in.

First up is debt counselling and debt review. At times, these two are practically the same thing, so pay close attention.

 

Debt counselling

Debt counselling is a service that helps over-indebted consumers (people with too much debt) to pay back what they owe.

It involves working with a debt counsellor to assess and optimise the ratio between a person’s income, expenses and debt and put legal processes in place to ensure that everyone agrees, the consumer is protected, and the debt can be repaid.

Specialist team member

Find out if you qualify to legally reduce your debt.

Try a quick 30-second online assessment to see if you qualify and get connected with a specialist who can help.

 

Debt review

Debt review is a legal process (most debt counsellors use it during debt counselling) that offers various benefits that make it easier to repay debt.

Debt review helps debt counsellors set up better repayment terms (reduce the cost), consolidate the debt (make it easier to pay and track), and offer legal protection.

Still with us? Because debt counselling and review work together, the terms are often interchangeable.

 

Debt consolidation loans

Debt consolidation loans are a type of loan that consolidates (combines) multiple debts under a new loan with better terms (like lower interest rates or a lower instalment). Unlike debt counselling and debt review, debt consolidation loans don’t offer the same type of legal protection.

 

To summarise: Debt counselling vs debt review vs debt consolidation loans

Debt counselling is a service that uses debt review, which is a legal process, to reduce monthly debt repayments, make the debt more affordable, plus offer other benefits to over-indebted consumers.

Debt consolidation loans offer similar benefits in the form of a loan but do not provide the same level of protection and intervention.

Now, the stage is set. So let’s get into more details.

A graphic that shows debt counselling and debt review grouped together with debt consolidation loans as a separate block

Which is better debt consolidation or debt counselling (debt review)?

The answer: It depends. Each of the options has pros and cons that play to different circumstances. Basically, the better option for you will depend on your financial circumstances.

Note that from here on out, we’ll lump debt counselling and debt review together (because the advantages and disadvantages of debt counselling [and other attributes] are so similar).

Let’s highlight the differences.

 

COMPARISON FACTOR DEBT COUNSELLING (DEBT REVIEW) DEBT CONSOLIDATION LOANS
Who is it for? People with too much debt. People who want to consolidate their debts for better repayment terms.
Eligibility (who can apply) Over-indebted individuals that are struggling to repay their debt.

Must be:

  • A natural person,
  • with reliable income,
  • and enough debt, 
  • who isn’t already registered for debt review.
Individuals with multiple debts that meet the necessary creditworthiness requirements to get approved.

Must have:

  • A decent credit score.
Process and duration It is a formal process (regulated by the NCR) that typically lasts 3 – 5 years.

*See: How long does debt review last?

It is an informal process, similar to taking out a loan, that varies in duration (can also be several years, depending on the amount of debt).
Effect on credit record Has a negative impact initially (relative to how good an applicant’s credit score is) but makes it easier to improve after debts are paid off. Has a negative impact initially that can be rehabilitated over time.
Cost Has debt counselling (debt review) fees

Which are set by the NCR.

Has fees and interest that are set by the lender.

*typically higher than other lenders. Do your maths first.

Legal protection Offers legal protection. No legal protection.
Advantages
  • Reduced monthly payments
  • Consolidation of debt
  • Protection from legal action
  • Mediation between borrower and creditors
  • No permanent record
  • A structured approach
  • Can present a lower monthly repayment depending on the loan agreement
  • Consolidates debt 
  • No restrictions on credit access
Disadvantages
  • Fees and costs
  • Restricted credit access
  • Fees and costs
  • No protection from legal action
  • No mediation between creditors
  • Higher risk

 

If you want to learn more about the ‘restricted credit access under debt counselling (debt review), check out our post on loans for debt review clients.

Need to reduce your debt bills?

 

Key takeaway

Debt counselling (debt review) and debt consolidation loans each have their place. Serving a specific purpose.

Both apply restructuring and offer new (often better in some way) repayment terms. One thing that stands out is the legal protection that debt counselling (debt review) provides. For anyone who is in or approaching hot water (creditors are constantly calling), this can mean a lot. Think—getting to keep your house or car.

On the other hand, a debt consolidation loan presents some of the same benefits (without legal protection) but does so without the formal process or credit restraints.

 

Final thoughts

There are many ways to take on debt that’s getting hard to manage. Debt counselling (debt review) vs debt consolidation loans puts two of the more popular options against each other, but it is a little like a split decision in boxing or a wine-tasting at your favourite wine farm. The winner depends on your perspective or your palette.

Want to learn more? Keep reading on Everycent.

Specialist team member

Find out if you qualify to legally reduce your debt.

Try a quick 30-second online assessment to see if you qualify and get connected with a specialist who can help.

Specialist team member

Debby will connect you with an expert.

Debt review assessment

Let's see if you qualify to reduce your total monthly debt repayment.

Please enter your total monthly debt repayment amount in ZAR:

Are you currently under any debt review?

Now, please enter your total monthly income in ZAR:

Are you currently employed?

Based on your answers...

You have a strong likelihood of qualifying.

You may connect with a human specialist and continue.